America Online, Inc. and multiple award winning author Harlan Ellison today announced a settlement of their four-year old copyright dispute.
Ellison sued AOL in April 2000 over concerns that unauthorized copies of his and the works of other authors were being distributed through the USENET newsgroup alt.binaries.e-book, which, at that time, could be accessed through AOL's and others' services. AOL blocked its users' access to the alt.binaries.e-book newsgroup immediately after Ellison filed his lawsuit.
In April 2002, AOL won a summary judgment dismissing Ellison's claims based on the limitations of copyright liability granted to Internet service providers under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act ("DMCA"). Ellison appealed that decision. In February 2004, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit partially affirmed and partially reversed the summary judgment. The Court confirmed that AOL could qualify for the DMCA's limitation on copyright liability as a "passive conduit" under the DMCA.
Both AOL and Ellison are pleased this case was able to draw the courts' and the public's attention to the issue of online piracy and advance the legal issues relating to copyrights in the digital world.
Ellison said: "Through this litigation, I have come to realize that AOL respects the rights of authors and artists, and has a comprehensive system for addressing the complaints of copyright holders. I would not have settled this case if I were not sure that AOL is doing what it can do to fight online piracy. Because not all Internet service providers are as responsible as AOL, and because individual acts of online piracy continue, I am glad to have called attention to the problem of online piracy through this litigation. As promised, I will be repaying every cent of the monies contributed to the KICK Internet Piracy Fund by writers and readers.
Curtis Lu, AOL's Deputy General Counsel, said: "AOL is glad to have played a role in confirming the DMCA's limitations on liability, which are available to services providers who provide access to content on the Internet and USENET. Consistent with the framework of the DMCA, AOL will continue to act responsibly in balancing the interests of copyright holders and the interests of its members."
As is usual with these things, there is a lot more that did not (and cannot) go into a press release of this nature. Also as is usual with these things, the wording of the press release leaves a lot to be desired from both sides' perspectives.
Further in this forum I say not. As time goes on, there will be more-extensive comments on the main site page for this matter. Keep in mind, however, that there remain issues that I will not be able to discuss, however much I might want to.