It's not all pro-tree up here in treehugger country. Some out-of-state termites have moved in…
Unfortunately, the initiative process in this state is easily abused, especially by outsiders and carpetbaggers who fled states with nonregressive tax structures for this one. This time around, it was Initiative 638, which bans transgender athletes from participating in Washington state high school girls' interscholastic sports.
Without regard to which sports. Without considering that at even high-school level, 90%+ of success in competitive sport is mental.†
And most particularly without regard to what the money poured into this indicates. (And keep in mind that these figures are only up to 26 October… and there were at least a dozen pro-638 commercials aired during sporting events on 31 October and 01 November, just before the election.)
| Expenditure Source | Position | Expenditure Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Let's Go Washington | Support | $8.035M | Subtotal | $8.035M |
| No Hate in WA State | Oppose | $4.121M |
| Defend Washington | Oppose | $0.564M |
| Wrong for Washington | Oppose | $0.007M | Subtotal | $4.692M |
| Grand Total | $12.727M | |
That's just the PACs. Just the post-approval campaign expenditures (again, only up to a week before the election). At the median pay rate for public-school high-school teachers in Washington of somewhere around $103k, that's 7 bits' worth about 127 teachers' salaries for a year, so as to (generously) exclude a dozen students from an extracurricular activity (that is often more of an inhibition to education than anything else). Even just the "support only" PAC's expenditures would have paid for close to 80 teacher salaries for a year… and none of the top contributors to that PAC actually have children competing with the "evil" of transgender Y-chromosome-bearers — who almost certainly have other significant medical challenges… although there's obvious competition with uncles-and-fathers-and-grandparents-living-vicariously-through-the-children at issue.
Looked at another way, this group of "concerned citizens" was willing to spend eight million dollars to exclude — to hurt — less than a dozen kids who were already being hurt by their underlying conditions. That's… not good financial sense. And it sure as hell isn't ethical, or consistent with the priorities established in McCleary₀ and completely discounts all of the other costs imposed. This is just about campaign expenditures.
Then, too, it's bigotry, and I'm intolerant of that kind of intolerance. Plus, this is pretty financial inefficient for a "financially sophisticated" hedge-fund manager. Apparently, inefficiency is just fine when buying morality.
† OK, you high-school football players, go up for a contested header against Abby. She's not even six feet tall.