null  
[self-portrait]Scrivener's Error Law and reality in publishing (seldom the same thing) from the author's side of the slush pile, with occasional forays into military affairs, censorship and the First Amendment, legal theory, and anything else that strikes me as interesting.
30 June 2003

20:45 [GMT-6]

Other People's Speech

The US Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit (based in Chicago, covering Illinois, Wisconsin, and Indiana) ruled today on Internet filesharing. In re Aimster Copyright Litigation. Judge Posner, who wrote the 23-page opinion for a unanimous panel (on the other hand, the majority of all Circuit Court opinions are unanimous… as there are only three judges), thoroughly trashed one of the main arguments of the "information wants to be free" advocates by noting that the First Amendment has little force when those asserting it are only repeating what others expressed and claim copyright in.

   Maybe information does want to be free. Copyright is not about information; it is about expression. In any event, the decision upholds the preliminary injunction issued against Aimster (now Madster) that shut down its file-sharing operation. Awwwwww.

Ritual disclaimer: This blog contains legal commentary, but it is only general commentary. It does not constitute legal advice for your situation. It does not create an attorney-client relationship or any other expectation of confidentiality, nor is it an offer of representation.

All material © 2003–09 except where otherwise indicated. All rights reserved. N.B. This blawg does not use the Creative Commons License, although I'm usually pretty good-natured about permissions for attributed reuse.

I approve of no advertising appearing on or through syndication for anything other than the syndication itself; any such advertising violates the limited reuse license implied by voluntarily including syndication code on this blawg.

None at present.

Archives  
 
 

Now live at the new site. I have arranged some of the more infamous threads that have appeared here by unravelling them from the blawg tapestry (and hopefully eliminating some of the sillier typos). Sometimes, the threads have been slightly reordered for clarity.

   
 
 

Links open in a new window.

Other Blawgs, Blogs, and Journals

These may be of interest; I do not necessarily agree with opinions expressed in them, although the reasoning and writing are almost always first-rate (and represent a standard seldom, if ever, achieved in "mainstream" journalism). I'm picky, and have eclectic tastes, so don't expect a comprehensive listing.

A blawg is sort of like a blog on legal issues, but usually has a lot more links to outside resources (other than other blogs) than does a typical blog. Scrivener's Error is a blawg, not just a blog. You can find other blawgs at < ? law blogs # >.

Searches

   www blogspot radio.weblogs
U.S.C. §
U.S.

 

Powered by Blogger
 
 

Optimized for Firefox 3.0 at 1024x768.